This assignment for practising with the cartoon guide consists of four steps. Each step has a number of questions that you answer one after the other on the worksheet.
German optician, fitting the spectacles: “What do you read now?” Dutchman: “Deutschland über Alles”. German optician: “Quite right: these spectacles suit you perfectly.”
Image description: Duitse opticien, die de bril opzet: “Wat lees je nu?” Nederlander: “Deutschland über Alles”. Duitse opticien: “Dat klopt: deze bril past u uitstekend”.
Step 1: Recognising people, objects and text.
- A: Read the text that goes with the cartoon.
- B: Which people do you see and what do they represent?
- C: Which objects do you see and what do they represent?
- D: What are the people doing?
Step 2: The subject.
- E: Which event or situation in history does the cartoon refer to? (Think of the role of the Netherlands during the First World War.)
Step 3: The artist and his opinion/message.
- F: Use what you learned from the link in ASSIGNMENT 1. Listen to the fragment again if you need to.
- G: Are people shown positively or negatively, perhaps in a very exaggerated way?
- H: Are objects shown positively or negatively, perhaps in a very exaggerated way?
- I: Is the caption neutral, or ironic, funny, critical, complimentary...?
- J: Is the title neutral, or ironic, funny, critical, complimentary...?
- K: Conclusion: What does the artist want to say with this cartoon?
Step 4: The cartoon as a source.
- L: Does the message of the cartoon match what you yourself know about this subject in history? Explain how informative, one-sided or even propagandistic you think this cartoon actually is, and why.