Why is having or developing historical awareness so important?
Historical awareness is about ‘placing in time’ people, developments and events. In what period did Louis XIV live? What were the norms and values at the time? How do we interpret his life now? Was he a good ruler or not? Are we even able to judge that now?
These are just a few of the questions involved, and many more questions of this kind can be imagined.
Without these questions there would be no such thing as 'history'. After all, they give us access to the core of history: what it is, and how we use (or misuse) it.
To improve their historical awareness and broaden their knowledge, students have to learn certain skills. According to the book “Geschiedenisdidactiek” by Arie Wilschut, these are the following three skills:
- Awareness of reality: distinguishing between fact and fiction;
- Awareness of historicity: distinguishing between the static (unchanging) and the changeable;
- Awareness of values: distinguishing between good and evil.
How does cartoon analysis contribute to this?
We believe that political cartoons increase students' historical awareness. Cartoon analysis ties in with the three characteristics of historical awareness described by Wilschut. Because of the often provocative nature of a cartoon, it presents a very clearly one-sided picture of a person or event. This can be linked directly to the awareness of reality and of values. The awareness of historicity can be increased by making comparisons with the present.
Conditions before starting cartoon analysis
Before students can start analysing political cartoons, two conditions must be met. The first is that the students have the relevant historical knowledge: they know the 'historical context'. The second is that the students know the symbols relevant to the subject and the physical features of the people involved (their faces).
In the case of this website, that means knowledge of (the life and work of) Louis Raemaekers and of the First World War.
This site provides information about Raemaekers. We assume that students have been taught about the First World War before they start on the assignments on this website.
The cartoon guide
In 2005 the history teachers' journal Kleio published a method for analysing political cartoons, distinguishing between the upper and lower years of secondary school. It set out step by step how students should go about analysing a cartoon. In this project we have based our work on the cartoon guide for the lower years published in Kleio. 2
Sources:
1 Wilschut, A., Van Straaten, D., & Van Riessen, M. (2004). Geschiedenisdidactiek. Handboek voor de vakdocent. Bussum: Coutinho b.v.
2 VGN Kleio (2005) ‘Loods je leerling door politieke cartoons. Een analysemethode als handvat voor de zelfstandig werkende leerling’.
Website: VGN KLEIO (opens in a new window)